Council Member Matt Kunz, Milton City Council

Kunz Tantrum . . . Ignore Him . . . Focus on the Future and Citizens

January 17, 2018

1516120757_2388

Some of you may have read the recent Milton Herald article “Kunz Video Takes Mayor to Task.”  If not, following is a link to the article:

Milton Herald: Kunz Video Takes Mayor to Task

Let me provide a little more context than the Milton Herald article provides.  Mr. Kunz has been publishing political videos online.  Mr. Kunz’s videos seem part of a larger strategy to disparage and discredit our most recently elected officials (even before they took office):  Mayor Joe Lockwood and new council members Laura Bentley and Peyton Jamison.  It is pure politics.  Kunz clearly views these council members (and Burt Hewitt) as his political enemies and worthy of his public disdain and admonishment.  (A warning about these videos . . . they are classic Kunz . . . smarmy and self-congratulatory.  Kunz is the greatest thing to happen to Milton . . . just ask him.)

22894449_1948987342010329_2020085489488174601_n (1)
Lockwood, Bentley, and Jamison

Mr. Kunz states in his introduction video that he is going to get “controversial” with his videos . . . citizens, hold onto your seats, we’re in for a rough ride.  And I have to give Mr. Kunz his props.  In his second video, he states that “it is unfortunate that we have elections.”  It is certainly provocative to question our democratic institutions . . . particularly coming from an American Studies major . . . and actually quite shocking coming from an elected official who has sworn to uphold the US Constitution.  Of course, this is not the first time that Mr. Kunz has taken issue with the pesky U.S. Constitution.  Along with former council members Lusk and Thurman, Kunz has asserted that some citizens speaking before Council are “violating” and “abusing” the right to free speech . . . and on occasion, Kunz and Company tried to infringe on that right.  Fortunately, a majority of council and the City Attorney have sided with citizens.

constitution-burning

Unfortunately, Mr. Kunz’s lament about the evils of democratic elections missed the mark; Kunz did not get the attention he was seeking.  So Kunz upped the ante (and lowered the tenor of civil discourse) by asserting that Mayor Lockwood sabotaged our city government by endorsing Laura Bentley and Peyton Jamison.  This time, Mr. Kunz found his mark and the Milton Herald published a story about his comments.

So given that the Milton Herald acknowledged Mr. Kunz, I thought I would also weigh in.  For quite some time, this blog has ignored Mr. Kunz.  The reason is that Mr. Kunz is isolated and irrelevant.  With his near-violent confrontation with Joe Longoria, following on the heels of a number of other missteps, Mr. Kunz has effectively sealed his political fate . . . politically speaking, he is a dead man walking and hence not worthy of much attention.

(Here is link to my previous post on Kunz’s council’s confrontation with Joe Longoria:  Milton Coalition: Kunz Council Meltdown)

Mr. Kunz seems to sense his irrelevance, and that is why he is acting up.  Kunz’s objective is to garner attention.  Think about it.  The election is over.  What’s the value in rehashing the election?  What’s the value of alienating new council members, even before they took their seats on Council?  Does Mr. Kunz really believe his comments will make Mr. Jamison and Ms. Bentley more likely to work with him or trust him?  Does Mr. Kunz really believe his comments are going to help our city and its citizens?  Of course not.  Kunz is only worried about saving his political neck.  At this point, he has calculated that he has nothing to lose.  He is not going down without a fight.  And if the city government and citizens suffer as a consequence . . . so be it.

child-temper-tantrum

The metaphor that best describes Mr. Kunz’s current strategy is “tantrum.”  Like a toddler who doesn’t get his way, Mr. Kunz is throwing a tantrum (thankfully, this time without the threat of violence).  And for the same reasons as a toddler:  to get attention and to get his way.  A few folks have expressed concern to me about Mr. Kunz . . . and yes, I agree that he is an embarrassment to the City.  However, my advice, particularly to our City government staff and City Council, is to ignore Mr. Kunz.  I suspect that Mr. Kunz will follow the Terrible Twos playbook and escalate his antics, which should make for good entertainment.  However, our city government needs to focus on citizens . . . a notion that Mr. Kunz does not get and never will get.

In the most recent election, citizens voted to shift power back to themselves (and away from Special Interests and their agents on Council, like Mr. Kunz).  Time, resources, attention, and mental energy spent on responding to Mr. Kunz are wasted.  The City should not be distracted from the main task at hand:  serving the community.  Mr. Kunz is stuck in the past and digging himself an ever deeper hole.  Let him keep digging . . . our City government should focus on the future and on citizens.

Tim Becker

********************************************************************************

BTW, the effects on the 2017 election of Mayor Lockwood’s endorsements are unclear, but he certainly was not responsible for even the greater part of Ms. Bentley’s 42-point blowout victory.  And in any case, Lockwood has the right–you could argue, even the obligation–to endorse candidates he believes will best serve the interests of the City.  Furthermore, it is noteworthy that Lusk did not post Matt Kunz’s radioactive endorsement of him, perhaps realizing such an endorsement would be a net-negative to Lusk’s campaign.

In a future post, I will be posting my own tough questions for Mr. Kunz.  And I have quite a few.  🙂

Council Member Bill Lusk, Council Member Matt Kunz, Council Member Thurman, Election 2017, Milton City Council

Three Sad Chapters in Our City’s Narrative . . . Let’s Turn the Page on Dysfunction in Our City

Ask yourself:  Are Lusk, Thurman, and Kunz really the best we can do?

Triumvarate

It’s hard to watch the news anymore.  And no, I am not talking about the national news.  I am talking about the local news.  Over the last 4 months, Milton has gotten more than its fair share of negative press.  And it is always the same 3 Council Members at the center of the dysfunction:  Lusk, Thurman, and Kunz.  Let me take you down Bad Memory Lane:

1499865000_4256

Chapter 1:  Thurman’s Redistricting – A Scandal of “Biblical” Proportions (July 2017)

In July, Council Member Karen Thurman was at the center of the redistricting scandal.  As you might recall, Ms. Thurman was moving outside of her district, but desperately wanted to keep her seat.  So Thurman found a legislator willing to sponsor a bill to redraw her district lines to include her new home.  The problem is that this change was made totally unbeknownst to Milton’s citizens.  Zero transparency.  Following is the story from the Milton Herald:

Milton Herald: Thurman Redistricting Scandal

This story elicited two very bizarre political speeches from Ms. Thurman.  In the first speech, Ms. Thurman descended from the council dais to deliver a speech to Council from the citizens’ podium.  Wrapping herself in an armor of Bible scripture, she delivered a rambling, holier-than-thou attack on her critics . . . we were all haters.

 

Then, a few weeks later and after the scandal had broken, Ms. Thurman again attacked citizens—this time from her lofty perch on the council dais.  Ms. Thurman cast aside her previous love-thy-neighbor theme in favor of Old Testament fire-and-brimstone.  In rambling tirade, Ms. Thurman screamed at citizens and even threatened the Milton Herald.  It was the epitome of a self-inflicted mortal wound.  Ms. Thurman had dashed all hopes for re-election and withdrew from the race for her Council seat.

 

However, Mr. Lusk later carried on the fight for Ms. Thurman, delivering a quite nasty speech in her defense while also excoriating fellow Council Member Joe Longoria.

 

Chapter 2:  Matt Kunz Meltdown – Heisman for Unsportsmanlike Behavior (August/Sept 2017)

Events in Milton got even stranger with Matt Kunz’s tirade against Joe Longoria prior to a special-called Council meeting.  Mr. Kunz squared up with Mr. Longoria and was yelling at the top of his lungs.  Longoria had the good sense to retreat to his seat.  During the council meeting, Kunz then doubled down on his bad behavior when Kunz tagged-teamed with Bill Lusk to humiliate Joe Longoria, who was recused from the discussion.  Following are stories from the Milton Herald and WSB:

WSB: Kunz Goes Off On Longoria

Milton Herald: Near-Violence Event Before Council Meeting

 

 

At a later council meeting, Kunz later made matters even worse when he later issued a weeping non-apology apology for his previous bad behavior.  See video.

 

In addition to his Heismann, Mr. Kunz recently won his merit badge for conflict of interest when it was revealed Kunz swore in the President of the Great Atlanta Homebuilders Association . . . the one and only Charlie Bostwick of Brightwater Homes . . . the developer whose project Kunz marketed in the Ebenezer rezoning.

kunz-swearing-in-bostwick 2

Chapter 3:  Bill Lusk Email Scandal:  Political Limbo – How Low Can You Go! (October 2017)

Not to be outdone, Bill Lusk wins the Oscar for Malfeasance and Misbehavior with his misappropriation and misuse of the Memorial Markers list.  Every major local news outlet covered that story.  No surprise.  After all, how often is a sitting council member reprimanded by the City Manager and City Attorney for a major ethics violation?  Mr. Lusk set a new low in city politics.  No matter how low the bar, Mr. Lusk somehow manages to shimmy his way under it . . . Lusk is a master of the political limbo dance.

Milton Herald: Milton Issues Apology for Improper Use of Emails

WSB: Longtime Councilman Using City-run Database to Solicit Votes

The Patch: Councilman Used Emails For Veterans Program To Promote Campaign Event

AJC: Milton Councilman Improperly Used Email Addresses From City

Chapter 4:  ??????????????????????????

After reading and watching these news stories, can you honestly say these Council Members (Thurman, Kunz, and Lusk) are the best we can do?  Do we really want our city to continue to be mired in dysfunction brought on by this triumvirate?  Citizens, with this election, let’s start a new chapter in City politics—one focused on smart land use, good governance, and listening to citizens.  Let’s begin by electing Laura Bentley to City Council.  Let’s leave behind the dysfunction of Lusk, Kunz, and Thurman.

*********************************************************

Thank you for your on-going support of good governance and smart land use in Milton.  Yesterday, the blog passed 10,000 hits . . . a major milestone.

Tim Becker

woohoo

Council Member Matt Kunz, First Amendment Rights, Milton City Council

Kunz Makes Tearful Apology At Council Meeting . . .

Kunz Apology

September 14, 2017

At last night’s city council meeting, Matt Kunz made a weeping apology for his reprehensible behavior at the previous city council meeting.  Over the past few weeks, Kunz has been all over the board with comments about his inexcusable behavior.  With his public comments and on-line posts, he kept digging a deeper and deeper hole for himself.  First, he stated he was merely “coaching” Joe Longoria to be a better “player.”  (It seems every situation in Mr. Kunz’s life lends itself to a football analogy.)  Then, he decided a better tack was to assert that Joe Longoria was the aggressor and he (Kunz) was just standing his ground.  Now he is apologizing for the “tone” of his comments and for kicking an injured player when he is down (yes, a fitting football analogy).

And of course, Kunz takes the obligatory swipe at citizens that have dared to criticize him at this blog and elsewhere.  Furthermore, he makes an assertion that has become a tedious refrain at council meetings.  Kunz and other Council members assert that citizens who criticize and expose local politicians are “violating the First Amendment” and “abusing their First Amendment rights.”  It is furthermore asserted that such criticism is slanderous and is hate speech that might lead to violence in Milton.  Ironically, the closest we have come to violence in Milton is Mr. Kunz’s rage incident a few weeks ago.

Sadly, Mr. Kunz is mirroring assaults (from both the extreme right and extreme left) on Free Speech (and other First Amendment rights) that we are seeing on the national level.  An example is the establishment of Free Speech “zones” on most college campuses–a painted box on some pavement in an obscure part of campus, where students are allowed to express their political views.  I suspect that we will soon see attempts by some council members to limit public comment at City Council meetings.  We have already witnessed a few attempts by council members to prod the City into issuing “official” positions on controversial policy issues.

Some City Council members’ profound ignorance and/or disregard for the Constitution should be of great concern to citizens, as council members take an oath to uphold the Constitution.  How can you uphold laws that you fundamentally don’t understand and/or don’t respect?

I will leave you will a little levity.  Following is a humorous YouTube video about a “YouTube Apology Service.”  (And yes, this blog can sometimes get a little snarky.)

Advocating For Accountability and Free Speech,

Tim Becker

YouTube Apology Service

YouTube Apology Service

Council Member Matt Kunz, Good Governance, Milton City Council

Kunz’s Monday Explosion Was No “Coaching Moment”

Browns Steelers Football

August 31, 2017

Citizens:

As you know the City has been swirling in controversy since Monday when two City Councilmen savaged a fellow City Council member over an innocent mistake.  There was little/no negative impact to the City from the missed qualifying deadline.  Rather, the negative press and associated embarrassment came from Mr. Kunz’s temper tantrum followed by his and Lusk’s unrelenting attacks on a colleague in the subsequent Council meeting.  This was not a “coaching moment” as Mr. Kunz originally asserted.  (Note:  he is now changing his story . . . read below.)  It was more like kicking a injured player while he is down.  Remember that Council Member Longoria was recused from the discussion and therefore could not defend himself.  And notice that there is a time when Longoria is tempted to respond (one can only take so much abuse) and Kunz warns him that he is not allowed to speak . . . another kick to the groin.

When finally allowed to speak, Longoria took the high road and merely apologized for the inconvenience he had caused the City.  That is called “manning up” . . . something Kunz is clueless about.

Of course, Kunz is now changing his story.  He no longer asserts that this was just a “coaching moment” or that his “passion” just got the better from him.  Now, he has completely changed his story.  He now asserts at his Matt Kunz Gov Facebook page:

“The fact is, and his own picture proves this, that the other Councilman left his chair and came to mine. That’s why we stood by my seat. I did not go to him. He came to me. I stood my ground. I will not make any judgments to the other Councilman’s intent.”

So you see Kunz is now implying that Longoria was the aggressor and that Kunz was merely defending himself.  That is quite a change to Kunz’s story.  I suppose the coaching moment/passion version of events was not cutting muster with citizens, so Kunz is now making himself out to be the victim.  I am very curious to see how imaginative Kunz’s third and subsequent versions of the confrontation might be.  A body double version might be interesting or maybe a version that includes divine intervention.  Perhaps readers of this blog might suggest plot twists for Mr. Kunz.

The problem for Kunz is that quite a few people witnessed the confrontation at various points in time.  My sense is that witness accounts would not corroborate Mr. Kunz’s story.  I only caught the worst of it, which was the last minute when Kunz was yelling at the top of his lungs and flailing about.  My sense is that the City needs to address this issue.  This includes interviews of the two participants and all witnesses to the event.  Based on an analysis of the events, the City should take appropriate corrective action.  The City needs to reassure citizens, particularly our youth, that it does not sanction such misbehavior.

Citizens, nearly 22 months have passed since citizens came together (in the CSO debate) to push for smart land use and good governance.  It was a David-and-Goliath struggle, pitting citizens against Special Interests and their agents on Council.  Through hard work and organization, citizens prevailed.  The truth was on our side; the CSO was defeated.  Then came the battle over Ebenezer.  Again, there was a long and protracted battle.  And again, citizens prevailed.  The truth of Ebenezer is now being borne out by the facts on the ground—i.e., the property is being developed at a far lower density than the defeated rezoning would have allowed.  Since Ebenezer, we have gradually advanced the cause of citizens to the point where citizens are in an advantaged position.  We are now witnessing the desperate acts of politicians who have fallen out of favor with citizens.  Citizens, we need to be careful not to be baited or otherwise dragged into the mud.  Mr. Kunz is his own worst enemy.  He is only hurting himself with his excuses, denials, and changing stories.  I am looking forward to Kunz’s Hail Mary Pass.  Citizens will be standing ten feet tall in the end zone.

giants-hail-maryjpg-bce8947f9a927c4e

Tim Becker

***********************************************************************************

Blog Statistics.  We have had around 550 views since Monday and over 700 viewings of Monday’s video clips.  Thanks for staying engaged.  Informed citizens are critical to good governance

Council Member Matt Kunz, Good Governance, Milton City Council

WSB News Story on Kunz Meltdown at City Council

Milton_city_councilman_gets_in____heated_0_8996894_ver1.0_640_360

August 30, 2017

Author:  Tim Becker

Citizens:

Following is a link to a WSB story on Council Member Matt Kunz’s meltdown at Monday’s City Council meeting.

WSB News: Council Member Kunz Temper Tantrum

I witnessed Kunz lose his temper on Monday.  As a consultant, I have worked for many dozens of companies.  I have seen several people lose their temper, mostly behind closed doors and not so up-close-and-personal.  However, I have never seen an outburst in the workplace like I witnessed on Monday.  I have never seen a person in the workplace publicly get in someone’s face like that.  I have never seen an incident so extreme that security was called.  And I honestly believe that what I saw on Monday would be a fire-able offense at many/most companies.  There was a time when such behavior–and other testosterone-fueled behaviors–were tolerated in the workplace; those days have long passed, except perhaps in Milton’s city government.

After a lot of time to think about it, the best excuse that Mr. Kunz could come up with is that he was applying a coaching technique.  He condescendingly asserts that he was helping Joe Longoria to become a better “player.”  By Mr. Kunz’s reckoning, he was just performing a good deed for his fellow man.  He was misunderstood.  And I suppose Joe Longoria and the rest of us are just a bunch of ingrates.  Is it Kunz’s intention to similarly “coach” his constituents to make them “better” citizens?

IMG_5105 - ver. 2

It is amazing that Kunz would be unapologetic and use the tired excuse that his extreme temper tantrum was just “locker room” behavior.  How many times have we, especially women, heard that before?  Boys will be boys, huh?

Kunz chalks it all up to passion.  However, I can tell you that what I witnessed was not passion.  It was clear for all to see that Kunz was out of control.  Staff were clearly concerned . . . so much so that the police were summoned.

Most importantly, let’s not forget who establishes the tone and culture of our city government:  our elected leaders.  They should be held to a (much) higher standard.  I have now been witness to no less than six extended outbursts from Council members in Council meetings.  And unfortunately, the bad behavior of some Council members has percolated to their appointees on committees.  In one incident (video to be released later), a committee chairman (with a history of bad behavior) had to be gently removed from a confrontation with the mayor by the City Manager, while police converged on the scene.  And with that incident, the City once again looked away.

senior boss screaming at small businessman

So it is fair to ask some questions to the city and ourselves?  Does Kunz’s meltdown really reflect our aspirations for the City?  Does it improve the culture of our City government (as Mr. Kunz ridiculously asserts)?  Is it more or less likely that citizens and staff will engage our Council (most notably Mr. Kunz) knowing that we might be “coached” in such a manner?  You get the point.  Kunz set a real poor example.  Mr. Kunz showed singularly poor leadership, no matter how you cut it.  And he continues to show poor leadership by making up a bunch of lame excuses for his behavior.  (Yes, I think it is fair to say that Mr. Lou Holtz would be more than disappointed in Kunz.)  I suppose it will be left to citizens to drag our City out of the gutter, where Mr. Kunz (and Mr. Lusk) have left it.

Advocating for Citizens,

Tim Becker

logo

********************************************************************************

The blog really went viral yesterday.  Tons of hits.  The posted videos have been watched many hundreds of times.  Thank you for your ongoing support.  To achieve better governance, the City needs your continued engagement.  Our hopes for improved governance lie with you, the citizens.  — TB

Council Member Matt Kunz, Ethics, Good Governance, Smart Land Use

Councilor Kunz Unashamedly Joins Forces With Developers Against His Constituents

August 19, 2017

The old cliche is that a picture paints a 1000 words.  The photos below were sent to us by a citizen.  They clearly show where Council Member Kunz’s loyalties lie.  It is crystal clear that Mr. Kunz has unabashedly joined forces with developers.  Mr. Kunz has long been a shameless advocate for developers in Milton, helping them bend, break, and change the rules for their benefit.  Citizens, if the photos below cause you concern, then please consider becoming engaged in local government.  Write to City Council.  Come to a City Council meeting and express your dissatisfaction with the influence of Special Interests.  We need to take back our city government from the developers and other Special Interests that exert far too much influence over our City Council.  Please get involved.

Following is an advertisement for a January 2017 event where Council Member Matt Kunz was the guest of honor/VIP.  He delivered a speech and swore in members of the Board of the Greater Atlanta Home Builders Association (GAHBA), which engages in significant lobbying on behalf of developers.

Matt Kunz AHBA Speaking Engagement

Following is a photo (taken in January 2017) of Council Member Matt Kunz swearing in the Charlie Bostwick, the new president of the Greater Atlanta Home Builder’s Association.  Disregarding his duty of judicial impartiality, Kunz aggressively and publicly promoted Mr. Bostwick’s proposed subdivision in the Spring/Summer of 2016.  Was this speaking and swearing-in gig payback for his strong advocacy on behalf of developers?

Kunz Swearing In Bostwick

Following is a photo of Council Member Kunz hobnobbing with executives of the Greater Atlanta Home Builders Association.  At the time this photo was taken, Mr. Ellis was a long-time registered lobbyist for the GAHBA.

Kunz at GAHBA Meeting

Tim Becker